They have no other choice but to free the Dark Lord. She replies that it made her feel like she’s capable of anything. Hilda reassures Sabrina that she did nothing wrong and that Zelda regretted her hostility towards Diane when she was still alive. Sabrina enters the kitchen and apologizes but Zelda makes a Shakespearean quote likening an ungrateful child to a serpent's tooth. She agrees and Prudence offers to send Melvin and Agatha with her, but Dorcas turns down the security.

Sabrina attempts to keep Lucy awake long enough for her to free them. She informs Zelda, Hilda, Ambrose, and Webster that she’s decided not to take Blackwood’s deal. They announce that Ambrose will be executed on the day that Father Blackwood returns from the Necropolis. She then asks him to never hate her, no matter what, but he can't understand why he ever would. Sabrina and Nick disrobe and anoint themselves, which involves running a blood dipped blade across their head and smear the blood off with the milk.

Zelda is shocked and asked why the Dark Lord would do such a thing. In reality, Sabrina and Ambrose remain unharmed. As he inquires further about Sabrina’s new school and she fumbles to come up with answers, he begins to suspect that she’s hiding something from him. Sabrina tells Zelda that she wanted to study conjuring but Blackwood says that it's too dangerous for her. She counted how many books she could read in that time, and that’s why every single one is important. Ambrose reassures Sabrina that it was a mercy killing that had to be done. Nick thinks that "Ms Wardwell" sent the scarecrow to kill her, deducing the rib to be hers. Sabrina tries to reassure Amalia that she is no threat to her and that she understands what she feels for Nick. Sabrina asks Zelda if she had been picked would she have let them do to her what they just witnessed. It’s light will shine on them, and they will reclaim their power. Ms. Wardwell asks what she means.Inside, Sabrina asks her family why there are organs hanging on the front door. He informs her of just how special she is and how she’s been chosen. When the mandrake asks why he won't let her fix her, Theo pushes her away and tells her that he is not broken. Blackwood asks how can a first-year, half-mortal student levitate, resurrect the dead, and kill angels. Harvey gets angry and punches Caliban. Sabrina and her aunts help the ghost children get revengeSabrina calls her Aunties. Roz realizes that she is not Sabrina, enraging the mandrake who summons magic and her eyes turn white. Sabrina asks if it hurts when Hilda dies. Sabrina disagrees and says that she has tapped into a different kind of magic that is not cause and effect based. Hilda informs Sabrina that Harvey stopped by because Roz is suffering from a witchy fever. Quentin says that they took them to the Quentin tells them not to go to the desecrated church because the Angels have sealed it with holy water and re-consecrated it. When Sabrina asks why Father Blackwood would kill her father and what work Edward left unfinished. Zelda refuses to discuss the matter and relieves Sabrina from her bridesmaid duties. Sabrina fails to open the jar in time to release Batibat, and so Ambrose picks the jar up and smashes it at Blackwood’ feet. Nick says he has found something that changes everything. Sabrina responds by recounting the story of Pandora's jar, arguing that the gods armed her for destruction and vengeance. They open the Academy’s doors to find Pan, Nagaina, Circe, and the pagans hidden within the fog. Some guys from the football team apparently beat Susie up and lifted up her shirt. Initially, witches were only allowed to wear black to their baptism, but that hasn’t been the rule for years. Sabrina goes to leave but Prudence asks where she's going and Sabrina says to Baxter High. He was a punching bag for Lucifer and a plaything for Lilith. They would rub their bodies with oils and bathe in the moonlight. She simply wants Nick back.